Previous Match Results
Match 2 has come to close and it was an absolute blow out. Jackaby snagged every single vote! Four Dead Queens is a fine cover, but this contest is for the very best of the very best. Voting might be easy now, but it’ll only get tougher and tougher as we get deeper into the rounds.
Round 1 – Match 3
Now we come the contest of the girl standing front and center. One holds a sign, the other wears a Hot Dog costume.
Hot Dog girl is a fantastic illustration. The art is well done and the style is cool. If I didn’t know if was a novel, I might think it’s the cover to a graphic novel. Notice the level of detail. It’s not just carnival rides in the background, there’s also a bunch of trees. These people aren’t just standing on some purple background. We can see the lines to the cement pads making up the ground. And the trash lying around sporadically is a really nice and realistic touch.
I haven’t read this one, but I’d wager that when being introduced to various characters In the book, readers are likely to flip back and see if that character appears on the cover.
The title font isn’t bad, but it could be better. I’d prefer to see something a little cleaner. Take that slight squiggle out of it and I’d have no issue at all. The colour is really great. Gives me the impression of perpetual sunset. Very interesting.
The Hate U Give goes the opposite way. The key is simple. Clean, white, ‘less is more’ approach. A simple cover done well is impressive. Simple design isn’t simple to do. But I can’t count how many times a cover with a lot of white space has drawn my eye.It can be sitting on a shelf surrounded by full-colour, graphically intense covers and still I end up looking to the one with white space.
The only thing I would have done differently is to give Starr’s sign a bit of colour or maybe an outline. Without, her hands, legs and top of her head all seem to be floating. It’s easy enough to put together that she’s holding a sign, but for a split second it’s just a bunch of autonomous body parts.
Which will you choose? Leave your vote in a comment below.
Note: Between education and career, I have over 15 years of experience in the field of graphic design. While I don’t pretend to know everything about design, and it will always be extremely subjective, I feel like I can speak about it with a modicum of authority (or at the very least, I don’t sound completely clueless.)
This one is tough: I want to vote for THUG because I feel like the whole point of all the white is to draw your attention to the contrast, which is Starr of course; but the colours in Hot Dog Girl are really appealing to me – and I’m not usually a pink and purple type of person.
However, I think I have to go with my gut and vote for Hot Dog Girl. 🌭🎡
The Hate You Give, its powerful and simple😁
Oh this is the first one I am considering tough! I think I will choose The Hate You Give. I like the other one because of the pastel colors but The Hate You Give gets the message across all in one simple image.
This one is harder to choose between. I love the simplicity and stark contrast of THYG. But I also really like the deceptively almost childish nature of Hot Dog. I start looking at it and bit by bit realise how much is really going on. By just a smidgen, I’m giving my vote to Hot Dog Girl.
This one is going to be close!
Hot Dog Girl (I like the squiggle in the title 😀 but it does give it even more of a Graphic Novel esque feeling)
I honestly was in the midst of writing a reply on Twitter but had to go back to work so here it is instead. If you go into this knowing the stories behind the covers, THUG wins every time without contest. Now going in blind? uhg. I LOVE the Hot Dog Girl cover so much. The color pallet is aesthetically pleasing and I adore the illustrative style. THUG is classic, clean, crisp. It is stunning.
I think I have to go with Hot Dog Girl though. I agree with you about the title, but I just loved this cover so much.